American Stonehenge (The Adventures of Jimmy and Andrew #1) by Mike Goldstein- middle grade sci-fi
American Stonehenge is adventurous, and suspenseful middle grade sci-fi with many interesting topics, beautiful illustrations, and moral lessons.
Disclaimer- Many thanks to author for review copy.
Synopsis
It’s his birthday, and Jimmy gets to pick out a dog at the humane society. Jimmy has wanted a dog for as long as he can remember. But he never imagined he’d find a pet that could talk to him telepathically!
It turns out that the dog is immortal, born in Egypt more than three thousand years ago. With the ability to read both canine and human thoughts, he has roamed the earth ever since, hoping to find others of his kind. Only after he meets Jimmy does he begin to discover clues to his elusive origins.
When Jimmy rescues Andrew from the pound, the first of their many adventures begins. American Stonehenge takes Jimmy and Andrew to the remote forests of northern Washington, where they accompany the boy’s archaeologist parents on the excavation of a newly discovered site. The find – a fully intact duplicate of Stonehenge in England – is shrouded in a mystery that Jimmy and Andrew must unravel.
How did this Stonehenge come to exist? Why do so many strange things happen around it? And what’s this telepathic dog been up to for the past three millennia? These mysteries and more are waiting to be revealed in Jimmy and Andrew’s first great adventure!
Review
American Stonehenge is adventurous first book in middle-grade series, The Adventures of Jimmy and Andrew, that follows unique relationship of an immortal dog, Andrew, and a nine yrs old, Jimmy, and their adventure.
Writing is simple and easy for middle-grade readers, told in third person narrative mainly from Jimmy and Andrew’s perspective, there is often short POV switches to adults in between. Most of the story takes place in 2007 but there are past timelines that started from the birth of Andrew in Egypt around 3000 yrs ago and snippets of his life till how he ended up in animal shelter where Jimmy found him.
I loved the way story started. Character introduction, concept, and build-up was interesting. I was curious to find out how Andrew is immortal, the mystery of missing friends of Pete, a Vietnam vet they meet living around the area of American Stonehenge, who are the forest people, and what will happen to Jimmy and his family once they start working on Stonehenge site. The story is more sci-fi than fantasy. There are many supernatural elements that make the plot a little far-fetched but it’s still enoyable.
There are many details about Stonehenge- when it was built and theories and superstitions around it, Native American lifestyle and culture, Vietnam vets, PTSD, nature vs technology, and many historical events that started from King Tut in Egypt to witch trials and iron age. There are many positive messages and moral values for kids. I loved the focus on the importance of preserving nature and having the right conscience and spiritual growth along with technological growth.
Illustrations are colorful and beautiful. I enjoyed the mystery and twists and turns but at the same time some revealations felt unbelievable. End is good with most of the mysteries wrapped up nicely while some mysteries remained to solve in next books of the series.
Why 3.5 stars-
Story is slow at some places. There is a little repetitiveness for clarification purpose. Dialogues are okay. As I said revelations are unbelievable and readers have to suspend their beliefs.
My main concern was with the characters. I couldn’t connect with any of them. Jimmy looked more mature than 9 yrs old. His parents are too trusting. Even though their trust was explained often I still found it hard to believe they let their son roam in the forest with a person they just met and hardly know.
Not all historical aspects are accurate. There is this picture depicting iron age in which men were wearing plain pants and women were wearing bras. I saw a comment about Plaid pants in reviews, I don’t know when it was invented but I agree about bra as I sure know there wasn’t a bra in this age.
I think readers of target audience will love this book but adults might find this okay.
Overall, American Stonehenge is enjoyable, adventurous, and suspenseful middle-grade sci-fi with many interesting topics, beautiful illustrations, and moral lessons.
I recommend this if you like,
Middle grade books
Unique concept
Adventurous stories
Informative Middle grade story
Fan of dogs
Stonehenge stories
Slow to steady pace
Theme of nature preservance
Many layers
Supernatural and sci-fi elements
Book Link
Goodreads | Amazon.in | Amazon.com | Amazon.co.uk
Thank you for reading! Let’s chat..,
What do you this about this book and review?
Have you read this or any book about Stonehenge?
Ypur favorite middle grade sci-fi/fantasy?
Blog | Instagram | Twitter | Facebook | Pinterest | Goodreads
Just in case you missed,,,
A Light in the Forest by Melissa Payne – Book Review
Carry On (Simon Snow #1) by Rainbow Rowell – Book Review
Sign up to receive email whenever I publish new post-
[instagram-feed feed=1]
Discover more from Books Teacup and Reviews
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
13 Comments
Carla
I do think my grandson would enjoy this one. I have read several middlegrade books where the characters does things that seem too old for them, then the next minute they act like babies. It can be frustrating. Nice review, Yesha.
Books Teacup and Reviews
Thank you, Carla! There is one scene like that but here character doesn’t act like baby but author shows things are different when we actually experience it. The kid here is much more brave and mature for his age.
britineppalove
I can’t get past the dog named Andrew hahaha
Lashaan Balasingam @ Roars and Echoes
Characterization sounds off in this one. I’d have trouble believing anything if I’m not even sure the characters act their age hahah Great honest review, Yesha!
Pingback:
Eustacia | Eustea Reads
I’m not sure if I would be able to take the anachronisms in the book! But I guess I really am just not the target audience, even though I’m normally fond of MG!
Books Teacup and Reviews
I also love middle grade but somehow this wasn’t as good as I expected.
WendyW
I like the sound of this. And I like stories about Stonehenge as the mysteries that surround that place are endless. I have been to Stonehenge in England as well as Carhenge in Nebraska.
Books Teacup and Reviews
Yes, it’s interesting mystery and there are many thoeries around it. This covers some of them but I can’t exactly say all of them because of my lack of knowledge in this subject.
Lady Tessa
This sounds like quite a mixed bag – great premise but inconsistent delivery that really didn’t easily let the reader’s disbelief to be effectively suspended. That’s too bad. Excellent review!
Books Teacup and Reviews
Thank you, Tessa! I love the concept and it sounds promising but it felt like too many things were included at the same time and many things felt unbelievable. But yes, kids would enjoy the imagination and going on adventure with charatcers.
Reading Tonic
Great review, Yesha! The concept is definitely unique…I mean most kids would love to have a talking pet, but one which was born in Egypt 3000 years ago- that’s unique! Bras in the Iron Age -even my imagination doesn’t go that far 🙂
Books Teacup and Reviews
It’s sure is good for kids. Haha, I was surprised to see men had pants and leather belts in that time and it turned out right in some aspect but women wearing bra was unbelievable. Thank you, Toni!